Issue 004 · Halloween buyer edition
Tricks, Treats & Shells
Spot the tricks before you buy and get the treats you paid for: a spooky-season guide to reading listings, asking sellers, and receiving live seafood.

No tricks, only treats
October is a busy month for seafood gatherings, which makes it a good time to sharpen your buying instincts. This Halloween buyer edition is about telling a treat from a trick—not because sellers are out to scare you, but because a clear order protects both sides.
We are not publishing price forecasts or claiming seasonal shortages. Availability changes by species, region, and harvest rules. The seller’s current listing and their confirmed answers are always your best guide.
Three tricks to watch for
The mystery unit: a price that does not say whether it is per pound, per dozen, per bushel, or per case. Always confirm the selling unit and, for crab, the size grade before comparing two listings.
The vanishing origin: a seller’s location is not the same as where the seafood was caught or farmed. Ask both. NOAA’s guidance reminds buyers that ‘wild’ and ‘farmed’ each describe many different systems, so a label alone is not the full story.
The phantom delivery date: live and fresh seafood is time-sensitive. Before checkout, confirm when it ships, how it is packed, and whether someone will be home to receive it.
The treat bag: what to ask
Send one simple message before an unfamiliar order: ‘Where was this harvested, what does one unit include, and how should I handle it when it arrives?’ Good sellers welcome that question. Keep the answer with your order in case anything needs to be sorted out later.
For bigger gatherings, try OnlyCrabs.live Wholesale. Post a request for quote with your quantity and party date, and sellers can reply with their price, delivery time and terms. You choose the one that fits—no costume required.
When the doorbell rings
Open seafood deliveries right away. Fresh seafood should be cold, and FDA advises discarding seafood that smells sour or ammonia-like. If something seems wrong, take photos and message the seller promptly through OnlyCrabs.live so the conversation is on record.
Then put it straight into the refrigerator or freezer and follow the seller’s handling notes. That is the best treat of all: seafood that arrives as good as it looked in the listing.
